Start a project ع
Start a project

contact.chokri@gmail.com

All notes

Design · November 18, 2026

The Design Dilemma: Everyone Sees the Result, No One Sees the Decision

Why design gets judged by taste, why the best design goes unnoticed, and how designers move from decorators to decision-makers.

Many faint squares and one orange square: the decisions nobody sees behind the one result everyone sees

Since I started working in web and design in 2013, I have learned that the hardest part of design is not the design itself.

The hard part is that design is a profession whose results everyone can see, so everyone assumes they understand it.

People rarely argue with an accountant about how a budget is prepared, or with an engineer about load calculations. But everyone has an opinion on colours, fonts, the size of the logo and where the button goes.

That is where the dilemma begins: the gap between what a designer actually does and what others think they do.

What can be seen gets judged by taste

Design is visible. That is both its gift and its curse.

Because it is visible, the conversation slides easily from “does this achieve the goal?” to “do I like it?”. How often does a team spend an hour on the colour of a button, then two minutes on the entire user journey?

Taste is not wrong, but it is personal. Design judged by taste alone becomes a contest of opinions, not a decision built on a goal.

And the person who will actually use the product is usually not in the room. The loudest voice in the meeting does not necessarily speak for them.

The best design is the one nobody notices

This is the paradox that hurts designers most.

When design works, it looks obvious. Users find what they are looking for, finish what they came to do, and never think about how. Everything feels “natural”, as if it took no effort at all.

When design fails, everyone notices: a form nobody understands, a page where information gets lost, one extra step that makes a customer leave.

So a good designer puts all their effort into making their work invisible, and is then asked to prove the value of something they deliberately made invisible.

Four sides that rarely agree

A designer never works for one side alone:

  • The client wants something that reflects their taste and vision.
  • The user wants to get their task done as quickly and clearly as possible.
  • The business wants a result: sales, requests, sign-ups or trust.
  • The technology sets limits: what can be built, by when, and at what cost.

These sides rarely agree completely, which is why “good design” depends on who you ask.

The designer is the one asked to find the point where they all meet, and is then usually judged on the colour.

The designer against themselves

Not all of the dilemma is external. Part of it lives inside the designer.

Every designer has taste, an identity, and a legitimate wish for their work to be beautiful and distinctive. But that wish can easily turn into defending the self rather than the goal.

The question I always ask myself is: am I defending this decision because it serves the user and the project, or because I like it?

If it is the second, stepping back is not defeat; it is part of being professional. The reverse is also true: if a decision rests on a clear understanding of the user and the goal, giving it up just because someone did not like it is not flexibility. It is abandoning the role.

From decorator to decision-maker

In many organisations, the designer is called in at the end.

The decisions come first: what is the service, who is it for, what is the content, what are the steps? Then the designer arrives to “make it look good”.

By that point the most important decisions have already been made, and some of them are wrong. No visual design can fix a product built on a wrong understanding of the problem.

The real value of design is at the start: defining the problem, understanding the user, and deciding what should exist at all. Colours and fonts are the last layer, not the first.

That is why I believe a designer who settles for the surface leaves their seat at the table to someone else.

AI settles part of the dilemma

Today, anyone can generate an interface, a logo or a landing page in minutes.

That can look like a threat to designers, and it really is one for a certain kind of work: work that sells only the “look”.

What the tools cannot decide on their own is: what should we build? For whom? Why? And what should we not build at all?

When producing the look becomes cheap, clarity becomes expensive. A designer who can understand the problem and order the decisions is worth more than ever.

How designers can get out of the dilemma

I do not think the dilemma will disappear, but it can be made much smaller:

  • Speak in outcomes, not taste. Instead of “this looks better”, say “this cuts the steps from five to three”.
  • Explain the decision, not the look. Every choice has a reason. If it has none, maybe it should not be there.
  • Join the project early. The later you arrive, the more you become the decorator of other people’s decisions.
  • Learn other people’s language. A designer who understands business and technology is treated as a partner, not an executor.

That is what moving between design, development and project management has taught me: the more of the table you understand, the less likely your role is reduced to the colour of a button.

In the end

The design dilemma is not that people do not value designers. It is that good design hides the effort that made it.

A designer who wants their role to be understood has to make the decisions visible, even when the design itself stays invisible.

Start a Project

Have a project in mind? Let's talk about what you need.

Whether you are defining a new digital product, improving an existing experience, building a website, or need support with a specific digital project, send me a brief overview and I'll suggest the best way forward.

A short brief is enough to start. I'll get back to you within two working days.

Your email is used only to reply to this message.

Direct

What happens next

  • I read the brief and reply within two working days
  • A 30-minute call to understand the situation
  • A written proposal with scope and a fixed price
Download CV